Carole King: Up on the Roof

Written by Amy Burton


In category: Song of the Day

Published April 10, 2020

This week, I’ll be sharing a new song each day to remind you (and myself) that how we use this time at home is as varied and limitless as our collective imagination.  There’s at least one song, if not hundreds, for everything we’re experiencing in this singular moment, and it wasn’t easy to pick five!  But I hope my choices delight, inspire, move, and comfort you, as they do me. 

Right smack dab in the middle of town

Carole King, hit songwriter of the Brill Building’s heyday (and inspiration for the Broadway hit musical, Beautiful),  says she came up with this melody while driving. Imagining a song entitled “My Secret Place,” she presented it to lyricist (and then-husband) Gerry Goffin. Inspired by the images in the 1961 film version of West Side Story, Goffin chose a tenement rooftop as the song’s urban haven.

The song was not only a major hit of 1962, but it has since been named to Rolling Stone’s list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time, and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame’s list of Songs that Shaped Rock and Roll.  While there are many notable recordings to choose from, from The Drifters to James Taylor, and Carole King herself, I chose Laura Nyro’s 1970 version for the way it captures the languid quality of a summer night in the city.  I love the moment when she suddenly catches fire on the phrase, “I get away from the HUST-lin’ crowds!”  The way Nyro sings it, there’s not a trace of loneliness in her solitude.  In fact, she revels in it, even if she does say “there’s room enough for two.”

Rolling Stone’s Jann Wenner said of Goffin’s lyrics, “From the internal rhyme of ‘stairs’ and ‘cares’ to the image of ascending from the street to the stars by way of an apartment staircase, it’s first-rate, sophisticated writing.”

But I like it because it makes me feel like dancing.

“Up on the Roof”
Carole King (b. 1942) and Gerry Goffin (1939-2014)
Performed by Laura Nyro

author: Amy Burton

select author’s name to read all of their posts

Amy Burton enjoys an eclectic career of opera, concert, and cabaret. She has sung with major opera companies and orchestras throughout the US and Europe, including the Metropolitan OperaNew York City Opera, Zürich Opera, L’Opéra de Nice, Scottish Opera, among many others. She has also sung at the White House. A lover of French song, Ms. Burton appears frequently with her husband, composer-pianist John Musto in recitals and cabaret. Recent concerts include New York’s Cafe Sabarsky, the National Arts Club, Wave Hill, Barcelona’s Liceu, the National Museum for Women in the Arts, Lincoln Center, and the Kennedy Center. Together they have made several recordings, including Songs of John Musto, Souvenir de Printemps, and Got a Little Rhythm for Bridge Records. A sought-after teacher, Ms. Burton is on the voice faculty at The Juilliard School, Mannes College of Music, and the CUNY Graduate Center DMA program. She also teaches, coaches and directs at SongFest at Colburn in Los Angeles. Amy Burton has been honored to perform on twenty-one NYFOS concerts, and is a proud member of the NYFOS Artists Council.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *